← ResearchDevon Bath

Which young cod survive their first summer

I started this as my honours thesis at Memorial University, testing an idea from the textbooks: that a summer full of predators leaves fewer but bigger young cod. It won the VP Research Award and became my first paper as lead author.

Co-authored with Dr. Robert Gregory, Dr. Paul Snelgrove and Dr. Emilie Geissinger. Published in the Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2024.

Why I asked

Young Atlantic cod spend their first summer in shallow eelgrass along the Newfoundland coast, and how they fare there shapes the fishery for years. The usual assumption is that predators pick off the smallest, so a summer with lots of predators should leave bigger survivors. Fisheries and Oceans Canada had been seining the same Newman Sound beaches every two weeks for more than two decades, which meant I could test that idea in the wild instead of in a lab tank.

What I did

  1. Framed the question

    Worked with my supervisors to turn a textbook assumption into a test I could run on existing field data.

  2. Organized the field records

    Cleaned and structured years of beach-seine catches and fish lengths from 12 sites in Newman Sound.

  3. Designed the comparison

    Picked 15 years that split cleanly into many or few predators and many or few young cod, using cut-offs set from the long-term data, not chosen to fit a result.

  4. Worked out who could eat whom

    Used each predator species’ mouth-size ratio to count only the fish big enough to swallow a young cod on each trip.

  5. Built the models

    Measured how each season’s size spread shifted, then modelled length and size spread in R.

  6. Made the figures and wrote the first draft

    Published in CJFAS in 2024, with me as first and corresponding author.

What I found

Young cod grew biggest when both predators and other young cod were scarce.

That was the opposite of what I expected. In years with many predators, young cod came in every size and stayed smaller on average, rather than losing their smallest members.

Years with few young cod

Years with many young cod

With few predators around, young cod ended the season clearly bigger…

…but when young cod were crowded, predator numbers made almost no difference.

Each point is the average length of young cod on one of six sampling trips, two weeks apart. Years are grouped by how many predators and young cod there were. Redrawn from Figure 5 of the paper.

Why it went the other way

In the paper I set out why fewer predators meant bigger young cod. Here are a few of the reasons.

In the paper: .

These are sketches of the ideas, not the paper's data. The predators are species from Newman Sound, Newfoundland, the same ones in my Eelgrass game.